Project Genesis

Unlocking Insights: My Journey into Scheduled Jobs

From Idea to Implementation

1. Initial Research and Planning

2. Technical Decisions and Their Rationale

3. Alternative Approaches Considered

4. Key Insights That Shaped the Project

• Data Relevance: The importance of selecting data sources that not only provided valuable information but also had a consistent update frequency became clear. This ensured that the data collected remained relevant and useful for analysis.

• Scalability: As the project evolved, we recognized the need for a scalable solution that could accommodate additional data sources and scraping jobs in the future. This insight led to the modular design of the scraping scripts.

• Error Handling and Resilience: During initial testing, we encountered various issues related to website changes and rate limiting. This highlighted the need for robust error handling and retry mechanisms in our scraping scripts to ensure resilience against temporary failures.

• Data Quality: The importance of data quality became apparent as we began analyzing the scraped data. Implementing validation checks and cleaning processes was essential to ensure the integrity of the data stored in S3.

Under the Hood

Technical Deep-Dive: Scheduled Jobs

1. Architecture Decisions

• Modular Design: Each job is encapsulated in its own script, allowing for easy maintenance and scalability. This modularity enables developers to add or modify jobs without affecting others.

• Scheduled Execution: The jobs are scheduled to run at specific intervals (daily or every 4 hours) using a task scheduler (e.g., cron jobs or AWS Lambda with CloudWatch Events). This ensures that data is collected regularly without manual intervention.

• Data Storage: Amazon S3 is chosen as the storage solution due to its durability, scalability, and cost-effectiveness. Each job dumps its output to S3, allowing for easy access and retrieval of data.

• Language Choice: Python and R are used for scripting, leveraging their rich ecosystems for web scraping and data manipulation. Python is particularly favored for its simplicity and extensive libraries, while R is used for its statistical capabilities.

2. Key Technologies Used

• Web Scraping Libraries:

  • For Python: Libraries like requests for HTTP requests and BeautifulSoup or Scrapy for parsing HTML.
  • For R: Libraries like rvest for web scraping and httr for making HTTP requests.

• Data Storage:

  • Amazon S3: Used for storing scraped data in a structured format (e.g., JSON, CSV).

• Task Scheduling:

  • Cron Jobs: For scheduling jobs on Unix-like systems.
  • AWS Lambda: For serverless execution of jobs, triggered by CloudWatch Events.

• Data Processing:

  • Pandas (Python): For data manipulation and cleaning.
  • dplyr (R): For data manipulation in R.

3. Interesting Implementation Details

• Dynamic URL Construction: Many jobs require constructing URLs dynamically based on parameters. For example, the mormon-reddit-submissions.py job might construct a URL to fetch the latest posts based on the current date or subreddit parameters.

  import requests
  from bs4 import BeautifulSoup
  
  subreddit = "mormon"
  url = f"https://www.reddit.com/r/{subreddit}/new/.json"
  response = requests.get(url, headers={'User-agent': 'Mozilla/5.0'})
  data = response.json()

• Data Dumping to S3: Each job includes functionality to dump the scraped data to S3. This is done using the boto3 library in Python or the aws.s3 package in R.

  import boto3
  import json
  
  s3 = boto3.client('s3')
  bucket_name = 'my-s3-bucket'
  file_name = 'apple_app_store_data.json'
  
  s3.put_object(Bucket=bucket_name, Key=file_name, Body=json.dumps(data))

• Error Handling: Each job includes error handling to manage issues such as network failures or changes in the website structure. This is crucial for maintaining the reliability of the scraping process.

  try:
      response = requests.get(url)
      response.raise_for_status()  # Raise an error for bad responses
  except requests.exceptions.RequestException as e:
      print(f"Error fetching data: {e}")

4. Technical Challenges Overcome

• Rate Limiting: Many websites impose rate limits on scraping. To overcome this, the jobs implement exponential backoff strategies, where the script waits longer between requests after encountering a rate limit error.

  import time
  
  def fetch_data_with_backoff(url):
      for i in range(5):  # Try up to 5 times
          try:
              response = requests.get(url)
              response.raise_for_status()
              return response.json()
          except requests.exceptions.HTTPError as e:
              if response.status_code == 429:  # Too Many Requests
                  time.sleep(2 ** i)  # Exponential backoff
              else:
                  raise e

• Data Consistency: Ensuring data consistency across different jobs that scrape similar data sources (e.g., multiple jobs scraping Reddit) can be challenging. Implementing a centralized logging system helps track the success and failure of each job, allowing for easier debugging and data validation.

• Handling Changes in HTML Structure: Websites frequently change their HTML structure, which can break scraping scripts. To mitigate this, the jobs are designed with flexibility in mind, using CSS selectors or XPath queries that are less likely to change.

Lessons from the Trenches

1. Key Technical Lessons Learned

• Data Handling and Storage: Regularly dumping scraped data to S3 is efficient for managing large datasets. It allows for easy access and retrieval while ensuring data durability and scalability.
• Job Scheduling: Using a consistent scheduling mechanism (like cron jobs or a task scheduler) is crucial for maintaining the frequency of data collection. This ensures that data is up-to-date and relevant.
• Error Handling: Implementing robust error handling and logging mechanisms is essential. This helps in identifying issues during scraping (e.g., changes in website structure, downtime) and allows for quick recovery.
• Rate Limiting and API Usage: When scraping websites or using APIs, it’s important to respect rate limits to avoid being blocked. Implementing backoff strategies can help manage this.
• Data Validation: After scraping, validating the data for completeness and accuracy is vital. This can prevent downstream issues when the data is used for analysis or reporting.

2. What Worked Well

• Diverse Data Sources: The variety of data sources (Apple App Store, Freddie Mac, Reddit, etc.) provided a rich dataset for analysis, catering to different interests and needs.
• Automation: Automating the scraping process reduced manual effort and ensured timely data collection. This allowed for more focus on data analysis and insights rather than data gathering.
• Modular Design: Each job is encapsulated in its own script, making it easy to manage, update, or replace individual jobs without affecting the entire system.
• Daily Updates: The daily frequency of most jobs ensured that the data remained fresh and relevant, which is particularly important for time-sensitive information like news and app rankings.

3. What You’d Do Differently

• Centralized Configuration Management: Instead of hardcoding parameters (like URLs or S3 bucket names) in each script, using a centralized configuration file or environment variables would enhance maintainability and flexibility.
• Enhanced Monitoring: Implementing a monitoring system to track job success/failure rates and performance metrics would provide better insights into the scraping process and help identify bottlenecks.
• Data Enrichment: Consider enriching the scraped data with additional context or metadata (e.g., timestamps, source reliability) to enhance its value for analysis.
• Version Control for Data: Implementing a version control system for the scraped data could help track changes over time and facilitate rollback if needed.

4. Advice for Others

• Start Small: If you’re new to web scraping, begin with a single source and gradually expand. This allows you to refine your process and tools before scaling up.
• Respect Robots.txt: Always check the robots.txt file of the website you are scraping to ensure compliance with their scraping policies.
• Document Everything: Maintain clear documentation for each job, including its purpose, data structure, and any dependencies. This will help future developers understand and maintain the code.
• Community Engagement: Engage with communities (like GitHub or relevant forums) to share your work and learn from others. This can provide valuable feedback and new ideas.
• Stay Updated: Web scraping techniques and best practices evolve. Stay informed about changes in web technologies, scraping libraries, and legal considerations to ensure your practices remain effective and compliant.

What’s Next?

Conclusion

Project Development Analytics

timeline gant

Commit Activity Heatmap

Contributor Network

Commit Activity Patterns

Code Frequency